Wednesday, 26 March 2008

Money Can't Buy Me...Food

A few months ago I wrote a short post on the increasing world’s food price (see here). In the past few days however, a few readers have emailed and left comments in my tag-board, asking for my view.

Since I am not currently in Brunei, I really don’t know the extent to which the global food inflation is affecting Brunei. But I’m sure, like everywhere else in the world, Brunei consumers must have also feeling the heat. For the benefit of all (in case someone is not sure why food prices have gone up), there are a few contributing factors:

1. The increase in the world demand for food: Giant countries such as China and India, whose economies have grown tremendously now have put pressure on the world’s food demand. As a result of a higher standard of living (due to the increase in income), the people in these countries now can afford to buy a larger variety of food resulting in increasing prices of wheat, rice, milk etc.

2. Rising input price: The main problem is the oil price. The soaring oil price is affecting the food price mainly in 2 ways. One, it increases the cost of transportation (land and/or sea). Two, it increases the price of fertilizers. When oil price increases, gas price also increases. Gas is needed to produce food fertilizer. Hence, fertilizer’s price goes up, so does the food price.

3. Climate Change: Flood and draught in many parts of the world are affecting the supply of food. When the food supply cannot meet the increasing food demand, then of course prices of food will go up.

4. Other market distortion: If you have never heard of biofuel, then by now, you should. And apparently it is also causing the food price hike. Wheat and corn for example, are now being used to produce biofuel. As a result, their prices have gone up and thus affecting the prices of other food. This problem is further aggravated by the trade policy of the developed producing countries who refuse to allow free trade for these commodities.

So anyone reading this should now understand why suddenly they find food prices have gone up (and it is not solely because the retailers have gone super-greedy, although some may have taken an advantage). I would actually expect for the effect to be stronger in Brunei since Brunei highly depends on imported food and we don’t have any (many) local substitutes. It is worrying really, just a few weeks ago, the Philippines for instance failed to buy enough rice for its inventories as a result of sales restrictions of rice in Vietnam, India and Egypt. Indonesia, on the other hand, warns of an impending unrest due to the rise in the prices of meat and tofu. (A Soft WARNING of rice shortage in South East Asia has been issued! And there is also a danger of a shortage of powdered milk! SO Please BE WARNED).

What can the government do? I DO hope the relevant authorities in Brunei will not just sit and watch and see how it goes. Other government around the world have taken actions. UAE recently has announced its intention to build a six-month staple food reserves, subsidising food and price freeze. Russia and China, have also issued food price freeze.

A list of staple food in Brunei should, by now be constructed. While I don’t expect the government to subsidise ALL food but I do expect some food price subsidies/food security packages are being planned for Brunei’s staple food (in addition to rice and sugar) such as cooking oil, flour, milk, eggs, chicken(?) and other food (Anonymousfoe: I hardly think mayonnaise should be included hehe). And this would be THE time to impose some price ceilings. Otherwise, we may be in a BIG, BIG trouble.

My advise to anyone reading this (as my previous post) is DO NOT WASTE FOOD! And however small your backyard garden is, try to plant some vegetables. You just never know…

Anyway, the Financial Times is an excellent place to get further information and latest news on the soaring food price (click here).

Salaam.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

The Indian Finance Minister, in a recent lecture at the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy in Singapore, blasted moves by rich agricultural producing nations to convert products into biofuels instead of food e.g. palm oil to biodiesel. Hence resulting in increased costs of food items (simple law of supply and demand).

Do you reckon he is right to blame higher food prices on initiatives to look for environmental-friendly alternatives other than oil? Or should a sub-continent and emerging economic power like India with a billion population push harder for her people to become more productive in agriculture in order to export more food cheaply to the world at large, Madam Rogue Economist? Can a small nation like ours become a big food producer?

ROGUE ECONOMIST said...

Dear anonymous,

I believe the issue is not about the production of biofuel itself, rather it's more about the trade policy the US and the European countries are having on the agricultural products used to produce the biofuel.

If you read the news, there is an ongoing debate about the (great)possibility of biofuel production to benefit the developing countries especially the poor, who can produce even more efficiently those products such as corn, sugar cane etc for the biofuel industry. But they can't! simply because the biofuel industry is concentrated in the developed countries. (Bear in mind, this industry requires infrastructure, high investment etc which are not available in the developing countries).

Furthermore, the US, for example is imposing about 25% tariff on imports of the agricultural products (such as sugar cane from Brazil) that can be used in the US biofuel production. This type of trade policy is causing the world's price hike of Corn which is the main crop used in the US biofuel. How? The US is a large exporter of corn. If the price of corn increases in the US then obviously it also increases in the importing countries. Corn price also affects other food prices as it is also used to feed the animals.

So, I guess it is not the question of whether or not India (or any other country) can produce efficiently (because I think they can) it is more the problem of market access to the biofuel industry in the developed countries.

You ask Can a Small Nation like us become a big food producer?
My answer is WHY NOT? We have the land, the money, the right climate. It's the WILL that we don't have! Our first priority however should be the national food security. Once our agriculture sector establishes then I believe the sky's the limit.
Now, I am really worried that in the event a global food crisis arises- when food producing countries ban their food export (which have happened), what will we eat? There is an extent to which money CAN buy. No?

Anonymous said...

No worries, my dear thinker-philosopher! The Almighty always works in mysterious ways, as people always say...

My late father used to relate to me the story of how during the Japanese Occupation of Brunei in the 2nd World War, Bruneians' key to survival (in the absence of rice) was Sago ("Ambulong" -> "Ambuyat") which is still in abundance until today. In fact, this carbohydrate-rich starchy food should be exploited in a really big way to be globally promoted with Brunei Darussalam as the largest producer in the world! (That will be the day, eh? *Hehe*:)

Are you a big fan of ambuyat, btw?

Katie-Ella said...

Hi - it's ironic isn't it, when we are actually faced with so much food waste in developed countries. (Estimated 30% in the UK) I'm sure even in Brunei people waste a lot of food. Or we simply eat too much!

Anonymous said...

Well, what can I say, Mrs Rogue Economist, your timely concern on the global food shortage issue is just starting to rear its ugly head, even as I am typing now.

Just last night I couldn't help sympathising with certain nations of the world in which their poor citizens are starving due to either no supply of staple food or simply no money to buy food items which have increased stiffly in prices. It is indeed a chaotic world we live in now...:( *sighs*

Even I am starting to feel the pinch in Brunei Darussalam, the Abode of Peace (and of course, the wealthiest country in the world!). Here I am a 44-year old man with 3 or 4 mouths to feed and I could barely make ends meet! I can't even afford to treat my 2 kids to KFC or McD or SugarB or Jollibee, what more to Sunday Splash at the Empire! Maybe once in a blue moon I could buy them cheap treats in Ayamku (but a trendy 14 year old boy and a fashionable 9 year old girl would rather not be seen by their fanciful and filthy rich friends to be seen eating there!)

So now I am resigned to the idea that I should start fasting, if not everyday, perhaps every Monday and Thursday of the week, Insya Allah (God Willing)...;)

If only I could talk personally to His Majesty Sultan Haji Hassanal Bolkiah Mu'izzadin Waddaulah, the Sultan and Yang Di-Pertuan of Negara Brunei Darussalam now, this is what I have to say: "AMPUN BERIBU AMPUN SEMBAH PATIK JUNJUNG DIAMPUN, DENGAN BERTAWAKAL KEPADA ALLAH SUBHANNAHU WATAALA DAN BERSELAWAT KEATAS JUNJUNGAN BESAR NABI MUHAMMAD SALLALLAHU ALAIHI WASSALAM, HAMBA DULI TUAN PATIK MENYUSUN JARI SEPULUH DAN BERENDAH DIRI MENJUNJUNG MAAF DAN PENUH KEAMPUNAN MERISTAKAN DAN JUNJUNG MENGADAPKAN USUL BUAH FIKIRAN AGAR JANGANLAH PARA MENTERI KABINET KEBAWAH DULI TUAN PATIK KAN LUAN LABIH-LABIH MENGAMPU KEHADAPAN MAJLIS DULI TUAN PATIK UNTUK BERBELANJA TELUAN BESAR-BESARAN MEMBAZIR WANG RINGGIT DAN TENAGA MENYAMBUT HARI KEPUTERAAN KEBAWAH DULI TUAN PATIK PADA TAHUN INI SEDANGKAN BANYAK HAMBA-HAMBA ALLAH DI DALAM NEGARA DAN DI MERATA DUNIA YANG FANA DAN SEMENTARA INI TERKAPAI-KAPAI KELAPARAN DAN MALAH TELAH BANYAK YANG MATI KEBULURAN!"

شركه كشف تسربات المياه بالدمام said...

شركة نور الحرمين
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالاحساء
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالدمام
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالقطيف
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالجبيل
شركة مكافحة حمام بالقطيف